25 Years of Noise: A Manifesto for Holy Silence
Written on the 25th anniversary of September 11, 2001
I. The morning the words ran out
I made my living with words.
I was trained as a journalist. I spent years in public affairs and crisis communication for energy and chemical companies, writing the sentences that get said when something has gone badly wrong. I studied how disputes are negotiated and how public arguments are framed. By the autumn of 2001 I was in Houston, teaching and advising at a graduate school of theology, still writing, still reaching for the perfect phrase.
Then came a Tuesday morning when every word was left wanting.
I remember the feeling of defenselessness over not being able to get a call through to one of my brothers who was in very close proximity to the explosions at the Pentagon. I remember knowing that there were no words to describe something that language could not hold. And I don't mean the inability of having nothing to say. Rather, the ridiculousness of having something to say and already knowing it would fall straight through. Just like all the statements and all the analysis that flew around every hour on the hour. All of it ended up being cacophonous noise stacked against an event that had gone silent at its center.
What I did not understand then, and have spent twenty-five years learning, is that the silence at the center was not an absence. It was the only thing in the room that was still speaking.
II. What I now believe happened
September 11, 2001, was many things: a mass murder, a geopolitical rupture, a wound that has not closed. I will leave those accounts to others who know them more intimately, like those who have to remember their dead. And all the soldiers, sailors, airmen, police, fire, and other first responders.
I want to say something more specific and, I think, more permanent.
That day was a catastrophe of hearing.
It was a catastrophe of hearing twice over.
It was a catastrophe of hearing because 19 men were certain they had heard God. They had not. They had heard something demonic, and they had obeyed it, and they had been formed for years inside a system that told them their hearing was sound. No tradition is immune to this. The history of my own is full of men who heard voices and burned people with them. The claim 'God told me' can be the most dangerous sentence any human being can say, and it is said constantly, in every language, in every century.
It was also a catastrophe of hearing because of what we did next. We answered a silence we could not bear with 25 years of noise. Cable news that never stopped. Arguments that never resolved. A war of words about a war. Then the internet arrived at scale and industrialized the whole operation, and now a generation has grown up inside a soundscape engineered so that no one is ever alone with anything for longer than eight seconds. We did not process what happened. We buried it under volume.
Max Picard saw this coming decades before the towers fell. In the modern world, he wrote, the individual no longer faces silence and no longer faces the community, but faces only universal noise - standing between the two, cut off from both, forlorn. That is a diagnosis of a civilization, and it is also a diagnosis of a person at three in the morning with a phone in his hand.
So: false hearing on one side, and the refusal to hear on the other. The remedy for both is the same, and it is not less listening. It is listening that has been formed.
III. What I found in the tradition
The Christian East has kept, for 18 centuries, a discipline of formed listening. It is called hesychasm - silence, stillness, the prayer of the mind descending into the heart. It was worked out in the deserts of Egypt and Sinai, refined on Athos, defended by Gregory Palamas, and carried forward in the Philokalia. It was never hidden. It was simply never offered plainly to people who are not monks.
It has also been accused, for almost as long, of being a sin against charity. Tomáš Špidlík put the accusation with real force in 1988: do these heroic forms of silence not sin by inverse excess? Does the man who withdraws not abandon his neighbor? Does he not, in fact, silence the very Spirit who speaks to persons through other persons?
That question is the reason for my doctoral work, and answering it is the reason for my priesthood.
Here is the answer I arrived at.
On Tabor, three disciples saw the uncreated light. That is the solitary ascent - imageless prayer, one person before God, the long climb. In the upper room, the Fire descended on a group of people, and what they received was not only light but speech - speech that arrived as sound and was heard as meaning, each in his own tongue.
I have named what descended there the uncreated silence: the unspoken speech of the Holy Spirit, an energy of God addressed to the spiritual sense of hearing. It is heard in prayer. It is discerned between persons. It is lived as pastoral care. I have called the receiving of it audiation - the hearing equivalent of illumination.
One trunk, two branches. The trunk is silence. One branch is more prayer. The other is the care of souls. Nobody who goes into that silence, honestly comes out of it indifferent to his neighbor. The silence is not the alternative to charity. It is where charity is told what to do.
IV. What Holy Silence is for
This is the mission of this ministry and I state it plainly.
One. To teach the Eastern Christian tradition of stillness - hesychasm, meditation, contemplation, the Jesus Prayer, the Holy Spirit Prayer - to people living ordinary lives outside the monastery. No theological degree required. Only the willingness to be quiet.
Two. To insist that this is not the baron emptiness of a mind. Orthodox meditation has a concrete foundation: a personal God who has spoken, who continues to speak, and who transfigures those who wait on Him in the illuminated darkness. It is not borrowed, not manufactured, and not dependent on trends that come and go.
Three. To treat discernment as a discipline rather than a feeling. Anyone can have an impression and call it God. The tradition has always known this, which is why it produced elders, confession, exagoreusis, the testing of thoughts, and the reading of hearts - an entire apparatus for checking whether what a person heard was the Holy Spirit, the self, or the enemy. Twenty-five years ago, the world was shown what unchecked certainty does. That apparatus is not an antique. It is public safety.
Four. To hold that spiritual guidance must be a school of inner freedom and never a form of captivity. The elder is not the center of the disciple's search. The elder builds the room in which the disciple learns to hear the Spirit for himself and then gets out of the way. Where this is inverted, the result is abuse, and I have written about it and will keep writing about it. Religion that captures a person can make him do anything. We have the footage.
Five. To go to people who are hurting. Grief, exhaustion, betrayal, a crisis of faith, a prayer that once came easily and now feels like words spoken into an empty room - this is where the work actually happens. You are not alone in that room, even when it feels like it.
Six. To keep the conversation going about deep, authentic prayer in order to bridge the chasm that lies beneath. I have spent many years seeking understanding, showing respect, working together, and engaging the other. The events of 2001 produced an enormous amount of talking about religion and very little praying. The corrective is not another panel. It is the discovery that the deepest, truest thing is the practice of standing before God with our minds in our hearts.
Seven. To resist the noise deliberately, as an ascetic act. Not as a lifestyle preference. Not as self-care. As warfare. The enemy's most effective modern tactic is not temptation but volume, and the surest way to keep a soul from hearing God is to make sure it never hears anything at all.
V. The Upper Room
Twenty-five years is long enough that a great many people now walking around have no memory of that morning. They have only inherited the noise.
To them especially I want to say this. The sound you have never been able to turn off is not the world. It is a condition, and it is reversible, and there is an ancient and thoroughly tested way out of it that does not require you to leave your job, your family, or your city.
Sit down. Be still. Stop explaining.
The disciples in the upper room were not doing anything impressive. They were waiting, together, in a locked room, after a catastrophe, with no idea what came next. What came was Fire, and what the Fire brought was speech - and the first thing they did with it was walk outside and start taking care of people.
That is the whole pattern. Silence, then hearing, then love of neighbor. It held on the day after Pentecost and it holds on the day after the towers.
Twenty-five years ago, I was a man of many and great words who already knew that my real calling was to be a man of NOT words ... holy silence. There is more said there than in any human conversation anywhere ever conceived. Come and listen to the Holy Spirit.
If you have a question or prayer request, please reach out here.
If you can donate, please click here.
Comments